# FemLite V5 Remaining TODO Status date: 2026-06-27 This file is the executable TODO list for the current 0.5.x development cycle. The phase status table is maintained only in `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. Rules for closing an item: - Completed task headings use `[x]`; open task headings use `[ ]`. - Code must be implemented in production modules, not benchmark-only helpers in `src`. - Tests must be automated through CTest or a documented extended test command. - Examples must live under `examples/`, one folder per case, with README, input, double-click run script and a check script when the case is used for acceptance. - Documentation must describe the algorithm, interface, user behavior and developer maintenance path. - Large generated result files must not be committed. ## V5.2 Dependency-Free Sparse Solver Hardening Boundary for this module: - Do not add third-party solver libraries. - Do not introduce an external solver process as a required or accepted production backend. - Do not expose third-party or external solver method/backend interfaces through the Fortran API, C ABI, CMake options or helper tools. - Legacy external solver numeric values must be rejected as invalid configuration and must leave the active internal solver settings unchanged. ### [x] DONE V5.2-1: Harden internal sparse solver workflows - Implementation: - Keep CG, BiCGSTAB, GMRES and the internal dense pivoting fallback as the production solver family. - Reject legacy external solver method/backend ids at the configuration boundary with no fallback solve and no state mutation. - Record method, preconditioner, iteration count, residual, matrix class and failure status for every static and implicit solve. - Reuse the existing CSR diagnostics to classify SPD, structurally symmetric and nonsymmetric systems before dispatch. - Tests: - Add or extend CTest coverage for SPD CG, nonsymmetric BiCGSTAB, nonsymmetric GMRES and dense pivoting matrices. - Add structural workflow checks for linear static, implicit Newmark and one nonlinear/contact correction path using internal solvers. - Add a C ABI check that the legacy external solver method value is rejected and does not change solver settings. - Acceptance: - Default builds have no third-party solver dependency. - No external solver constants, C ABI prototypes, CMake targets or helper tools remain in the module. - Static, implicit and nonlinear/contact paths solve through internal dispatch and report diagnostics. - Legacy external solver selection never silently falls back to an internal solve. - Completion evidence: - `linear_solver_solve` records CSR matrix class, initial residual, final residual, relative residual, method, preconditioner, iteration and status. - `linear_solver_cg`, `solver_implicit`, `implicit_inp` and `c_api` cover the internal diagnostic path and legacy external method rejection. - `linear_solver_cg` now also covers the internal dense pivoting solve on an indefinite matrix; `solver_implicit` covers a nonlinear correction path that restores user settings after an automatic CG-to-GMRES fallback. ### [x] DONE V5.2-2: Document no-external-solver policy - Implementation: - Update user, algorithm and developer documentation to state that the core module is dependency-free with respect to sparse solvers. - Document the supported internal solver methods, preconditioners and diagnostics. - Document that external solver interfaces have been removed and legacy external method values are invalid. - Tests: - Keep default CTest working without any optional solver package. - Add source/documentation checks when practical to prevent reintroducing third-party solver build options. - Acceptance: - V5 planning and release documentation no longer list external solver enablement or adapter interfaces as current-version acceptance items. - Completion evidence: - User, algorithm, interface, test and developer documentation now describe the no-external-solver policy and the internal solver diagnostic fields. ## V5.3 Mortar / Augmented Lagrangian Contact ### [x] DONE V5.3-1: Promote two-block contact to nonmatching mortar benchmark - Implementation: - `examples/contact_two_blocks_compression` uses a nonmatching 4-facet lower master face against a 1-facet upper slave face. - The checker derives pressure profile, max gap, weighted gap, multiplier residual and augmented multiplier metrics from contact CSV output. - `pressure_profile.csv` is written in the result directory for benchmark inspection. - Tests: - `check_contact_results.py` checks active contact, master-facet coverage, pressure range, weighted penetration, multiplier residual, augmented multiplier growth and VTK output. - CTest `example_contact_two_blocks_compression_benchmark` runs the example and calls the check script through `tools/testing/run_example_smoke.py`. - Acceptance: - The nonmatching pressure benchmark passes in the default Release CTest path. - Example README documents the nonmatching mesh, reference metrics and limitations. - Completion evidence: - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R example_contact_two_blocks_compression_benchmark --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26. ### [x] DONE V5.3-2: Promote sliding contact to large-sliding mortar-friction benchmark - Implementation: - `examples/contact_block_sliding` now uses a nonmatching 4-facet lower master surface and a 1-facet upper slave surface. - The upper block is force-driven over the master surface while normal augmented multiplier history and tangential stick/slip/friction-work output remain coupled through the production contact path. - Restart continuity for contact friction and multiplier state is covered by the module-level `restart` CTest; the example benchmark focuses on the large-sliding friction trajectory. - Tests: - `check_contact_results.py` writes `sliding_profile.csv` and checks multiple master facets, multiple active candidates, accumulated slip, stick/slip counters, tangential force, positive friction work and VTK output. - CTest `example_contact_block_sliding_benchmark` runs the full example and checker through `tools/testing/run_example_smoke.py`. - Existing `contact_omp1`, `contact_omp4` and `perf_contact_pair_omp_consistency` continue to cover OpenMP contact consistency at module/performance-smoke level. - Acceptance: - Stick/slip transitions are reported. - Frictional work is nonnegative within tolerance. - Restart continues multiplier and friction history without jumps in the module restart regression. - Completion evidence: - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R example_contact_block_sliding_benchmark --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26. ### [x] DONE V5.3-3: Add shell/solid contact benchmark coverage - Implementation: - Added `examples/shell_shell_contact` with an S4-to-S4 contact benchmark. - Added `examples/shell_solid_contact` with an S4 slave surface contacting a C3D8 solid master face. - Both examples use the existing contact pair, mortar force/output and augmented multiplier paths; no special-case production path was added. - Tests: - Each example has a local checker that writes a compact profile CSV and checks active contact, force norm, gap residual, augmented multiplier, master search and VTK output. - CTest entries `example_shell_shell_contact_benchmark` and `example_shell_solid_contact_benchmark` run the examples and checkers. - Acceptance: - At least one shell-solid and one shell-shell contact case pass automated checks. - Completion evidence: - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "example_shell_(shell|solid)_contact_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26. ## V5.4 Mohr-Coulomb And Strength Reduction ### [x] DONE V5.4-1: Finish material-point acceptance tests - Implementation: - Cover triaxial compression, triaxial extension, pure shear and tensile cutoff. - Record active branch or return-map mode for each test. - Tests: - Add explicit tolerance checks for stress, plastic multiplier and branch id. - Acceptance: - All material-point tests pass without substep explosion. - Tangent or algorithmic stiffness limitations are documented. - Completion evidence: - `test_material_mohr_coulomb` now covers triaxial compression, triaxial extension, pure shear, tensile cutoff, mixed return, branch id, post-return yield tolerance and plastic increment checks. - `test_material_mc_driver` and `test_material_mc_envelope` cover path driver diagnostics, branch counts, limited status, tangent diagnostics, envelope margins, safety ratios and reduced material parameters. - Algorithm, detailed design, interface, test, user and developer documentation now describe the Mohr-Coulomb equations, input format, state variables, driver diagnostics and engineering tangent limitations. - Targeted CTest command: `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "material_mohr_coulomb|material_mc_driver|material_mc_envelope" --output-on-failure`. ### [x] DONE V5.4-2: Replace strengthReduction placeholder with MC benchmark - Implementation: - Update `examples/strengthReduction` to use real Mohr-Coulomb material input. - Add strength reduction search controls and output safety-factor history. - Output plastic zone and displacement control probe. - Tests: - Add check script for final safety factor range, bracket convergence and plastic-zone extent. - Acceptance: - Safety factor lies inside documented tolerance. - Check script fails if the solve only runs linear elastic behavior. - Completion evidence: - `strength_reduction_slope_static.inp` now uses `MC_SOIL` with `*MOHR COULOMB` friction, cohesion, dilation, tensile cutoff, residual parameters and reduction factor fields. - `tools/benchmarks/strength_reduction_benchmark.f90` links the production core and calls the Mohr-Coulomb yield path plus strength-reduction driver/report modules to generate safety-factor history, summary, plastic-zone and displacement-probe files. - `check_strength_reduction_results.py` rejects the old elastic placeholder and checks converged safety factor, real stable/unstable bracket, plastic zone activation, displacement probe signs, VTK and node output. - CTest `example_strength_reduction_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with `FS=1.21125`, 8 trials, 3 stable trials, 5 unstable trials and 2 active plastic probes. ## V5.5 Linear Buckling And Cyclic Symmetry ### [x] DONE V5.5-1: Add analytic buckling verification - Implementation: - Add a small column or beam benchmark with known Euler critical load. - Assemble prestress/geometric stiffness through the production path. - Tests: - Check first eigenvalue relative error. - Acceptance: - Relative error and mode normalization are documented. - Completion evidence: - Added `examples/euler_column_buckling` with README, benchmark input, double-click `run_case.bat` and `check_buckling_results.py`. - Added `tools/benchmarks/euler_column_buckling_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it assembles beam bending stiffness, uses production `geom_beam2d_column_stiffness`, calls `buckling_dense_solve`, compares against `buckling_euler_column_load` and writes summary/mode CSV files. - Hardened `buckling_dense_solve` so the internal dense Jacobi eigensolver iteration budget scales with problem size. - CTest `example_euler_column_buckling_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with relative error `3.27660856E-05`, residual `1.50014805E-11` and `phi^T K_G phi = 1.0`. ### [x] DONE V5.5-2: Upgrade corrugated shell benchmark - Implementation: - Replace static-only smoke with buckling eigenvalue analysis. - Add cyclic sector model and full-model comparison when feasible. - Write mode shape output through modal output path. - Tests: - Check critical load range and cyclic/full consistency. - Acceptance: - README documents eigenvalue, mode count, cyclic wave number and tolerance. - Completion evidence: - Added `tools/benchmarks/corrugated_shell_buckling_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it builds a sixteen-sector reduced corrugated-shell periodic buckling model, calls production `buckling_dense_solve`, validates the selected wave through `fem_cyclic_symmetry` and writes modal output through `modal_write_csv`. - Added `corrugated_shell_buckling_benchmark.inp`, `check_buckling_results.py`, updated `run_case.bat` and rewrote the example README with reference metrics and tolerances. - Replaced CTest `example_buckling_corrugated_shell_smoke` with `example_buckling_corrugated_shell_benchmark`. - CTest `example_buckling_corrugated_shell_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with selected wave 4 load `453.031407`, critical wave 8 load `393.369677`, cyclic/full relative error `1.25473461E-16` and modal residual `1.31855319E-12`. - `source_size` CTest passed after the new benchmark tool was added. ## V5.6 High-Fidelity Roll Forming ### [x] DONE V5.6-1: Add real roller kinematics to contact workflow - Implementation: - Ensure rigid roller rotation contributes to relative tangential velocity. - Couple roller translation, down-feed and angular velocity in input/control. - Output roller force, torque, contact pressure band and friction work. - Tests: - Unit test roller kinematics and relative velocity sign. - Example check for nonzero rolling traction and stable energy trend. - Acceptance: - Removing angular velocity changes tangential traction in the check case. - Completion evidence: - Added production `roller_regularized_traction` to `fem_rigid_roller`; it uses the same roller tangential velocity path and a smooth `tanh(slip/reference_speed)` friction factor so spin changes traction magnitude, not only slip speed. - Extended `test_rigid_roller` with a spin/no-spin comparison that verifies angular speed changes slip and regularized traction. - Added `tools/benchmarks/roll_forming_kinematics_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it drives production roller pose, schedule, contact kinematics, regularized traction and roll metrics to output roller history and summary. - Added `examples/roll_forming/roll_forming_kinematics_benchmark.inp`, `check_roller_kinematics.py` and updated `run_case.bat`/README. - CTest `example_roll_forming_kinematics_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with mean slip `0.4` with spin vs `0.2` without spin, mean traction `289.208274` with spin vs `228.478247` without spin, max traction delta `60.7300272` and positive roller torque `14.4604137`. ### [x] DONE V5.6-2: Add plastic forming and springback benchmark - Implementation: - Upgrade `examples/roll_forming` to include plastic workpiece and unloading. - Output residual displacement, plastic zone and springback metric. - Tests: - Check forming force range, positive plastic work and springback sign/range. - Acceptance: - Example is no longer only an elastic contact surrogate. - Completion evidence: - Added production roll metrics helpers for residual displacement and springback ratio, with `test_rigid_roller` coverage. - Added `tools/benchmarks/roll_forming_springback_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it drives production roller kinematics, regularized traction, roll metrics and J2 small-strain material updates on a compact multilayer workpiece section, then solves unloading release curvature by bending moment balance. - Added `examples/roll_forming/roll_forming_springback_benchmark.inp` and `check_springback_results.py`; `run_case.bat` now runs the springback benchmark after the friction smoke and kinematics benchmark. - Targeted checker passed on 2026-06-26 with springback ratio `0.473154068`, residual displacement `0.0316107559`, plastic work `1.11591736e-05`, 56/81 active plastic points and residual moment absolute value `8.92778801e-11`. ## V5.7 Cohesive Adhesion / Decohesion ### [x] DONE V5.7-1: Add cohesive single-point acceptance tests - Implementation: - Cover loading, unloading, mixed-mode damage and complete decohesion. - Track damage, maximum opening, energy and status. - Tests: - Verify nonnegative dissipated energy and irreversible damage. - Acceptance: - Restarted state preserves damage and maximum opening. - Completion evidence: - `test_cohesive_contact` now drives one cohesive integration point through bonded loading, mixed-mode damage, unloading, reload and complete decohesion. - The path records damage, maximum opening, effective separation, dissipated energy and status through `fem_cohesive_state` and `fem_cohesive_metrics`. - The test verifies nonnegative energy increments, irreversible damage, failed-state zero traction, failed-area metrics and restart preservation of damage, maximum opening, maximum effective separation, energy and status. - Targeted command passed on 2026-06-26: `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "cohesive_contact|source_size" --output-on-failure`. ### [x] DONE V5.7-2: Upgrade ball adhesion/decohesion example - Implementation: - Use cohesive law/state in `examples/ball_adhesion_decohesion`. - Output force-displacement curve, cohesive energy and decohesion area. - Tests: - Add check script for hysteresis, peak pull-off force and dissipated energy. - Acceptance: - Example fails if cohesive damage is not activated. - Completion evidence: - Added `tools/benchmarks/ball_adhesion_cohesive_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it discretizes the adhesive ball/membrane patch into concentric rings and drives compression, unloading and pull-off through production `fem_cohesive_law`, `fem_cohesive_state` and `fem_cohesive_metrics`. - Added `ball_adhesion_cohesive_benchmark.inp` and `check_cohesive_results.py` under `examples/ball_adhesion_decohesion`; `run_case.bat` now runs the original contact smoke and the cohesive benchmark. - The benchmark writes `adhesion_history.csv`, `adhesion_summary.csv` and `decohesion_profile.csv`, covering force-displacement hysteresis, cohesive energy, peak pull-off force, damage and decohesion area. - CTest `example_ball_adhesion_cohesive_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with peak pull-off force `119.246023`, min compression force `-362.051100`, dissipated energy `0.451891017`, hysteresis area `0.898170568` and final failed fraction `1.0`. ## V5.8 Particle / Flexible Container Coupling ### [x] DONE V5.8-1: Complete particle acceptance primitives - Implementation: - Cover particle free fall, wall collision, particle-particle pile and particle-facet coupling with production modules. - Output mass, momentum, kinetic energy, dissipated energy and max overlap. - Tests: - Add checks for mass conservation, bounded overlap and nonnegative dissipation. - Acceptance: - Diagnostics are available through Fortran and documented output paths. - Completion evidence: - Added `pstep_diag_values` to expose `particle_step_diag` mass, momentum, kinetic energy, step dissipated energy and max-overlap values through the Fortran module API. - Added CTest `particle_acceptance`, covering free fall, damped wall rebound, three-particle pile contact and particle-facet load transfer with the production particle state/contact/step/facet modules. - The test checks mass conservation, bounded overlap, nonnegative dissipation, kinetic/momentum diagnostics and particle-facet nodal force balance. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "particle_acceptance|source_size" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26. ### [x] DONE V5.8-2: Upgrade dynamic grain container example - Implementation: - Replace pressure surrogate with real particles and flexible container two-way force mapping. - Record particle count, contact count, container displacement and energy. - Tests: - Add example check script for particle statistics and container response. - Acceptance: - Example fails if particle forces are not mapped back to the FEM model. - Completion evidence: - Added `tools/benchmarks/dynamic_grain_container_benchmark.f90` outside `src`; it loads a pressure-free flexible S4 container, applies real particle-facet contact through `particle_fem_apply_all`, maps nodal loads through `fsph`, advances the FEM response and preserves particle reaction forces for particle integration. - Added `dynamic_grain_container_benchmark.inp`, `flexible_container_grain_benchmark.inp` and `check_grain_container_results.py` under `examples/Dynamic_Grain_Packing_of_a_Flexible_Container`; `run_case.bat` now runs the old smoke and the V5.8 benchmark checker. - The checker rejects pressure surrogate input and verifies particle count, contact count, mapped nodal force, downward container response, mass conservation, bounded overlap and nonnegative energy. - CTest `example_dynamic_grain_container_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-26 with 4 particles, 4 facet contacts, `mapped_steps=40`, max mapped vertical load `3.68E+01`, minimum center displacement `-7.29240354E-06` and max overlap `3.00615680E-03`. - Full Release command `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26 with 106/106 tests. ## V5.9 Benchmark, Performance And Documentation ### [x] DONE V5.9-1: Build V5 benchmark matrix - Implementation: - Add a table mapping every V5 completed capability to an example directory, test name, reference metric and tolerance. - Keep smoke and benchmark tiers separate. - Tests: - Default CTest remains fast. - Extended benchmark command runs the V5 acceptance checks. - Acceptance: - No completed V5 capability relies only on a smoke test. - Completion evidence: - Added `docs/v5_benchmark_matrix.md` with V5.2-V5.8 capability-to-test mapping, example directories, output files, reference metrics and acceptance tolerances. - Added CTest label `v5_acceptance` to current V5 acceptance tests and benchmark examples while preserving existing default CTest behavior. - Documented the extended command `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -L v5_acceptance --output-on-failure`. - The extended command passed on 2026-06-26 with 35/35 tests. ### [x] DONE V5.9-2: Refresh documentation after each capability closes - Implementation: - Update requirements, architecture, detailed design, algorithms, interface, test plan, user manual and developer manual only with factual implementation details. - Keep status markers only in `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. - Acceptance: - Status-table wording remains confined to `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. - Completion evidence: - Updated README, `docs/01_requirements_specification.md`, `docs/02_software_architecture_design.md`, `docs/03_detailed_design.md`, `docs/04_mathematical_model_and_algorithms.md`, `docs/05_interface_control_document.md`, `docs/06_test_and_verification_plan.md`, `docs/07_user_manual.md`, `docs/08_developer_manual.md`, `docs/v5_development_plan.md` and `docs/v5_benchmark_matrix.md` for V5.8 and V5.9-1 changes. - Core docs describe the implemented particle algorithm, staggered particle-container coupling, benchmark CLI, output files and verification commands without adding phase status markers outside `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. - Documentation checks verified no phase-status markers in the core docs listed above. ## V5.10 Acceptance And Release ### [x] DONE V5.10-1: Create V5 acceptance report - Implementation: - Add `docs/v5_acceptance_report.md`. - Summarize completed, incomplete and postponed items from `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. - Include exact test commands, environment and results. - Acceptance: - Report identifies every remaining deferred item, reason, risk and effect on users. - Completion evidence: - Added `docs/v5_acceptance_report.md` with the current V5 acceptance scope, Windows Release environment, exact CMake/CTest commands, 106/106 default CTest record and 35/35 `v5_acceptance` record. - The report summarizes completed V5.2-V5.8 capabilities, remaining engineering gaps, and postponed or out-of-current-module items with reason, risk and user effect. - README now links to the V5 acceptance report. ### [x] DONE V5.10-2: Final release hygiene - Implementation: - Ensure worktree is clean except intended release files. - Clean generated root result files. - Run default CTest and any enabled extended benchmark tests. - Acceptance: - Release branch or main merge has reproducible test output. - README and version metadata match the release state. - Completion evidence: - Root-level generated result files (`history.csv`, `nodes_*.csv`, `elements_*.csv`, `reactions_*.csv`, `contact_*.csv`, `result_*.vtk`, `femlite.log`) were removed after the final full CTest run. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -L v5_acceptance --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26 with 35/35 tests. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-26 with 106/106 tests. - README and version metadata are aligned on `0.5.0`. - V5 release changes are prepared as the intended release-file set on `main`; committing these changes makes the worktree clean for the current release checkpoint. ## V5.11 Complete Spherical Cap Postbuckling Benchmark Boundary for this module: - The existing `examples/spherical_cap_with_central_point_load` benchmark only verifies the reference geometry, material scale, displacement-control setup and small-strain shell reaction samples. - A complete case must reproduce the geometric nonlinear postbuckling path from `models.sme.spherical_cap_with_central_point_load.pdf`; do not mark it complete while it only runs a linear or small-strain displacement sample. - The minimum viable production path is a corotational S4 shell with direct crown displacement control and reaction-force postprocessing. A more general continuation/global-equation or arc-length path can follow after that. - Current partial progress: - `generate_spherical_cap.py` now emits the Shell-16 baseline deck and a Shell-4 PDF-mesh diagnostic deck `spherical_cap_displacement_control_shell4.inp`. - Both decks record `METHOD=ARC_LENGTH_OR_DISPLACEMENT_CONTROL` and `SHELL_GEOMETRIC=YES`; the checker now rejects inputs that omit the explicit geometric shell request and can attempt the Shell-4 nonlinear direct-displacement path when `FEMLITE_SPHERICAL_CAP_NONLINEAR=1`. - Added production module `src/element/fem_shell_corotational.f90` and wired S4 internal force/stiffness to use reference/current frames, deformational local translations and rigid-rotation subtraction when `SHELL_GEOMETRIC=YES` or method 4 is active. - Added production S4 membrane initial-stress geometric stiffness in the corotational tangent path: existing membrane resultants contribute `integral (grad N)^T N (grad N) dA` to local translational `u/v/w` blocks before the standard current-frame global transform. - Added production `src/solver/fem_dload_tangent.f90` for shell `DLOAD P` follower-pressure tangent. The nonlinear static/Newmark Newton matrix now includes `K_ext = -dF_ext/du` for current-geometry shell pressure loads, and `test_shell_pressure` verifies the assembled tangent against finite differences. - Added production `src/solver/fem_linear_solver_dense.f90` and nonlinear correction fallback sequencing in `fem_solver_implicit`: the correction solve first uses the configured method, then for failed CG corrections retries internal GMRES, BiCGSTAB, dense pivoting, and finally bounded diagonal-regularized dense pivoting before returning a real nonlinear failure. User-visible solver settings are restored after the fallback. - `*NONLINEAR CONTINUATION` now parses `SHELL_GEOMETRIC`, `GEOMETRIC_SHELL`, `COROTATIONAL_SHELL` and `S4_COROTATIONAL` as validated booleans; invalid values fail without mutating the current continuation state. - `test_shell_internal` covers S4 rigid-body objectivity, small-rotation agreement, elastic corotational algorithmic tangent finite-difference column agreement, non-symmetric tangent acceptance and prestress-delta membrane geometric stiffness activation; `test_shell_pressure` covers the follower-pressure load tangent; `implicit_inp` covers the new INP controls. - `check_spherical_cap_results.py` now uses separate signatures for the default small-strain samples and the optional nonlinear route. The optional `FEMLITE_SPHERICAL_CAP_NONLINEAR=1` route must show post-peak load drop and restiffening if it reaches `-6.2 m`; a monotone linearized curve can no longer pass as nonlinear postbuckling evidence. - Default CTest remains on small-strain Shell-16 samples because the current core still lacks the full Shell-4/8/16 postbuckling solve chain: generalized Riks/arc-length equations, all load-family follower tangents, bending/shear prestress terms, plastic/multilayer shell algorithmic tangents and validated `-6.2 m` convergence. With the internal linear fallback chain enabled, the optional Shell-4 nonlinear route now progresses past earlier linear subsolver failures and ends with true Newton nonconvergence. Do not mark V5.11-1/2/3 complete from this diagnostic route. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "example_spherical_cap_point_load_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27 for the default small-strain baseline. ### [ ] TODO V5.11-1: Add geometric nonlinear shell capability - Implementation: - [x] Add a production geometric nonlinear S4 shell path suitable for large displacement and finite rotation response, preferably starting with a corotational Mindlin/Reissner formulation. - [x] Include elastic membrane, bending, transverse shear and drilling stabilization in a way that is compatible with the current shell section and material data. - [x] Add a verified elastic corotational algorithmic tangent for Newton iterations by finite-differencing the production S4 internal force; the tangent is intentionally not symmetrized because it represents the residual derivative in the current corotational frame. - [x] Add prestress-delta membrane geometric stiffness so independent membrane resultants contribute geometric stiffness without double-counting the current elastic membrane response. - [x] Preserve existing linear S3/S4/S6/S8 behavior and tests; the nonlinear path must be opt-in through the nonlinear static solve path or an explicit element capability switch. - [x] Reject non-ELASTIC S4 corotational tangent assembly with a material error instead of silently falling back to the old engineering tangent while plastic/multilayer shell algorithmic tangents remain open. - [ ] Extend the algorithmic tangent beyond the current elastic S4 path to plastic/multilayer shell sections, bending/shear prestress terms and the remaining nonlinear shell terms required by the PDF postbuckling benchmark. - Tests: - [x] Add unit/module tests for rigid-body rotation objectivity, small-rotation agreement with the current linear shell, finite-difference tangent-column agreement and non-symmetric tangent acceptance for a deformed S4 patch. - [x] Add module coverage proving prestress-delta geometric stiffness activates and disappears when the stored prestress is cleared. - [x] Add module coverage proving J2 shell material is rejected when `shell_geometric_nonlinear` requests the unsupported S4 corotational tangent. - [ ] Add at least one nonlinear shell regression that reaches a reference postbuckling or snap-through path and would fail as a purely linear shell sample. - Acceptance: - [ ] A curved shell patch under large prescribed displacement converges with Newton/cutback without relying on benchmark-only code. - [x] The response is invariant under rigid-body rotation within documented tolerance. ### [ ] TODO V5.11-2: Implement displacement-control continuation output - Implementation: - Support crown prescribed displacement increments from `0` to `-6.2 m` and record the reaction at every accepted increment. - Compute and write nondimensional curve data: `wn = -w/th`, `Fn = -F*a/(E*th^3*2*pi)`. - Keep direct prescribed displacement plus reaction as the first supported path for this benchmark. - Add a follow-up design note for a general load-factor/global-equation or Riks/arc-length continuation path when the load pattern is not a single controlled point displacement. - Tests: - Add API or CLI coverage proving reaction output is available at each accepted nonlinear static increment. - [x] Add checker logic that detects nonmonotonic load response after the first limit point when the optional nonlinear spherical-cap route completes. - Acceptance: - The benchmark produces a load-displacement CSV with the critical-load, softening and restiffening segments visible. - The solver does not silently fall back to a single linear static sample. ### [ ] TODO V5.11-3: Upgrade spherical cap example to full PDF benchmark - Implementation: - Extend `examples/spherical_cap_with_central_point_load` so the generated inputs can run the PDF shell meshes with 4, 8 and 16 meridional elements. - Keep the current full 3D cap geometry, fixed rim, crown displacement control, `a = 10 m`, `th = 0.203840 m`, `E = 210 GPa`, `nu = 0.3` and cap angle `pi/4`. - Add benchmark output files for load-displacement curves and sampled table comparisons. - Tests: - Upgrade `check_spherical_cap_results.py` to compare against the PDF Shell-4, Shell-8 and Shell-16 nondimensional tables. - Require the Shell-8/Shell-16 paths to show load drop after the first critical point and later restiffening. - Add tolerances for the PDF values, starting around 5-15% depending on the final shell formulation and mesh behavior. - Acceptance: - CTest `example_spherical_cap_point_load_benchmark` validates the full postbuckling path, not only the current linear displacement-control samples. - The checker fails if the curve is monotone linear or if the old smoke input is restored. ### [ ] TODO V5.11-4: Document solver limits and completed benchmark evidence - Implementation: - [x] Update the user manual, mathematical model, detailed design and developer manual with the current geometric nonlinear shell formulation and continuation workflow, including the elastic algorithmic tangent and current solver limits. - [x] Update the example README with the exact PDF table references, output files, tolerances and known formulation limitations. - [ ] Update the benchmark matrix only after the full checker validates the postbuckling path. - Tests: - [x] Run targeted nonlinear shell tests, the spherical cap benchmark, example layout, and the relevant default CTest subset. - Completion evidence on 2026-06-27: `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "shell_internal|shell_pressure|solver_implicit|linear_solver_cg|example_spherical_cap_point_load_benchmark" --output-on-failure` and `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "implicit_inp|c_api|csr_diagnostics" --output-on-failure` both passed. - Acceptance: - [x] Documentation clearly separates the old small-strain sample coverage from the completed postbuckling benchmark. - [ ] The final acceptance note includes exact commands, dates and curve metrics. ## V5.12 V5 Development Plan Open Backlog Boundary for this module: - This section mirrors the still-open `PARTIAL` and `DEFERRED` items in `docs/v5_development_plan.md`, especially the 0.5.2 `two_arches` reference route and the engineering close-out priorities listed in section 20.3. - Do not duplicate release hygiene items already closed in V5.10 unless the development plan still describes a concrete remaining engineering action. - A compact benchmark can be kept as regression coverage, but it cannot close a task that explicitly calls for a production workflow, full continuation path or high-fidelity reference case. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-1: Finish `examples/two_arches` PDF reference route - Source: - `docs/v5_development_plan.md` marks `examples/two_arches` as `PARTIAL / 0.5.2 TARGET`. - Current coverage is PDF geometry, 30/75 shell mesh, contact activation, 1.2 mm upper-arch midpoint displacement and explicit micro-step stability. - Implementation: - Replace the literature-route acceptance path with static continuation or an equivalent global-equation workflow; keep the dynamic micro-step only as geometry/contact binding regression. - Implement or emulate the global equation `disp_upper - max_disp*para = 0`. - Use `disp_upper` as the upper-arch midpoint vertical displacement, `max_disp = 60 mm`, and advance `para` from `0` to `1`, initially with `range(0,0.02,1)` or an equivalent continuation step sequence. - Keep the PDF geometry and mesh values explicit in the generator/input: `Ri_upper = 80 mm`, `Ri_lower = 100 mm`, shell width/thickness `d = 3 mm`, upper arc `80 deg`, lower arc `100 deg`, upper 30 mapped shell elements and lower 75 mapped shell elements. - Keep material values explicit: lower arch `E = 40 GPa`, `nu = 0.2`, `rho = 1`; upper arch `E = 20 GPa`, `nu = 0.3`, `rho = 1`. - Apply the reference in-plane constraints, lower-end fixed constraints, out-of-plane `y` constraints and upper-arch vertical edge-load control. - Use frictionless shell-shell contact with upper arch as source/slave and lower arch as destination/master. - Output `two_arches_path.csv` with at least `para`, `disp_upper`, edge-load factor, active contact count, max gap/penetration, residual and iteration status. - Tests: - Upgrade `examples/two_arches/check_two_arches_results.py` to reject the dynamic micro-step path as literature-route PASS evidence. - Verify geometry coordinates, 30/75 mesh counts, material values, `disp_upper=max_disp*para` residual, contact active set, bounded gap, nonnegative/bounded contact work and load-displacement path shape. - Add a CTest entry or update the existing benchmark entry so `example_two_arches_contact_benchmark` validates the static continuation route. - Acceptance: - `examples/two_arches` passes a reference-route checker without relying on explicit dynamic micro-steps. - The checker compares load-displacement/path metrics against documented reference indicators from `models.sme.two_arches.pdf`. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-2: Close industrial mortar / AL contact gaps - Source: - V5.3 remains `PARTIAL` in `docs/v5_development_plan.md`. - Implementation: - Complete industrial-grade AL/mortar consistent tangent behavior for nonlinear contact paths. - Expand restart coverage beyond current active/released/open multiplier audits where the development plan still calls for more scenarios. - Add larger OpenMP contact benchmarks that exercise nonlinear long paths, not only compact or performance-smoke paths. - Clarify node-based surface to general element master support: direct support, conversion to facet constraints or explicitly deferred path. - Tests: - Add nonlinear long-path contact benchmarks with force, tangent, restart and OpenMP consistency checks. - Ensure internal BiCGSTAB/GMRES paths expose true status for nonsymmetric or difficult tangent systems instead of hiding failures. - Acceptance: - Contact mainline is closer to a production constraint solve, with documented convergence behavior and restart continuity on long paths. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-3: Close Mohr-Coulomb structural workflow gaps - Source: - V5.4 and `examples/strengthReduction` remain `PARTIAL / FOS PASS`. - Planned INP selector: - [x] Add a production INP-level nonlinear continuation selector: `*NONLINEAR CONTINUATION, METHOD=value`. - [x] Accept numeric method ids `1` through `5` and stable symbolic names so old benchmark decks can stay compact while user-facing decks remain readable. - [x] If the keyword is omitted, use method `1` as the default production algorithm. - [x] Reject unknown method ids/names at input validation time; do not silently fall back to a different nonlinear path. - [x] Record the selected method in nonlinear diagnostics, path CSV files and VTK/run summaries where applicable. - Completion evidence: - Added `NLC_*` continuation method enums and `nonlinear_continuation_method` default control state. - Added INP reader support for `*NONLINEAR CONTINUATION, METHOD=value`. - Added `tests/data/c3d4_static_nonlinear_continuation.inp` and `implicit_inp` coverage for default method 1, ids `1..5`, symbolic names, invalid values and state preservation on parse failure. - Added continuation method diagnostics to strengthReduction nonlinear chain/cloud/progress CSV output and checker validation. - Targeted CTest command passed: `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "implicit_inp|example_strength_reduction_benchmark" --output-on-failure`. - Implementation: - Add structure-level automatic trial re-solve for strength reduction. - Define and implement nonlinear instability criteria suitable for structural strength-reduction workflows. - Audit and document the Mohr-Coulomb engineering tangent in structural solves, including convergence status and substep counts. - Extend `examples/strengthReduction` beyond the current FOS curve so it can reproduce the PDF material case 2, `alpha = 45 deg`, `FOS = 1.525` result with about `0.3 m` displacement-cloud scale. - Implement method `1` / `TWO_STAGE_LOAD_STRENGTH` as the default route: first converge the real gravity/load state at strength factor `F=1.0`, then keep the external load fixed and continue the material strength reduction factor from `1.0` to the target factor. - [x] Add production nonlinear static control `static_ramp_load` so the implicit static solver can either ramp external loads by pseudo-time or hold the assembled external load factor fixed. - [x] Route `strength_reduction_benchmark --nonlinear-chain` through the method-1 two-stage solve when `nonlinear_continuation_method == 1`. - [x] Route `--nl-write-cloud` through the same two-stage method-1 workflow, with the progress CSV tracking the fixed-load strength-factor stage. - [x] Keep default `*NONLINEAR CONTINUATION` behavior as method `1` and continue writing the selected method id to nonlinear chain/cloud outputs. - [ ] Reduce method-1 runtime and nonlinear iteration cost enough for the 0.75 m PDF cloud case to run to full target factor in a documented longrun command. - [x] Implement method `2` / `ADAPTIVE_TARGET_NEWTON` as a production nonlinear static step-size controller that targets a bounded Newton iteration count, grows after cheap accepted steps and shrinks after expensive accepted steps, cutbacks or failed convergence. - [x] Add INP controls `TARGET_NEWTON`, `GROWTH`/`GROWTH_FACTOR` and `SHRINK`/`SHRINK_FACTOR`, with validation before state mutation. - [x] Add production diagnostics for target increment, accepted increment, next target increment, accepted Newton count and adjustment reason. - [x] Write method-2 diagnostics to strength-reduction nonlinear chain/cloud/progress CSV files and validate them in the example checker. - [x] Add module tests for production adaptive stepping and INP parsing, including invalid-control preservation. - [x] Implement method `3` / `TRUST_REGION_DAMPED_NEWTON` as a safeguarded Newton path with correction-size limits and residual-merit damping for high-load nonlinear segments. - [x] Add INP controls `TRUST_RADIUS`, `TRUST_MIN_RADIUS`, `TRUST_MAX_RADIUS`, `TRUST_GROWTH`, `TRUST_SHRINK`, `TRUST_ACCEPT_RATIO` and `TRUST_GOOD_RATIO`. - [x] Clip Newton corrections by the active trust radius before the residual-merit line search. - [x] Reject residual-increasing damped corrections with a reproducible solver error, allowing the existing cutback/rollback path to respond. - [x] Update the trust radius from residual merit reduction, damping and line-search rejection count. - [x] Record trust radius, next radius, damping factor, merit ratio, rejection count and trust adjustment in production diagnostics and strength-reduction CSV/summary output. - [ ] Implement method `4` / `ARC_LENGTH_OR_DISPLACEMENT_CONTROL` for limit-point paths where pure load or strength-factor continuation cannot pass snapback or localization events. - [x] Add production accepted-increment path storage in `fem_control`, including control parameter, controlled DOF count, prescribed/actual displacement norms, constraint residual, reaction path, generalized work, Newton iteration and convergence status. - [x] Record direct prescribed-displacement continuation in `implicit_solve_nonlinear_static` for `METHOD=4`, using the same `load_factor * amplitude` boundary value that the solver enforces. - [x] Expose the path through `fem_get_continuation_path_count`, `fem_get_continuation_path_row` and `continuation_path.csv`. - [x] Add low-level solver and INP/API regression coverage for accepted increments, reaction output and zero constraint residual. - [ ] Complete the general augmented load/displacement/arc-length equation path with extended unknowns and consistent tangent, so snapback and nonmonotonic paths can be followed without benchmark-specific orchestration. - [ ] Implement method `5` / `MC_SUBSTEPPING_SEMISMOOTH` for local Mohr-Coulomb material stability, including stress-point substepping, active-set diagnostics and semismooth branch handling around corners. - [x] Add INP controls `MC_MIN_SUBSTEPS`, `MC_MAX_SUBSTEPS`, `MC_TARGET_STRAIN`, `MC_YIELD_TOL` and `MC_PLASTIC_LIMIT`, with validation before mutating the previous valid control state. - [x] Route production `MOHR_COULOMB` material updates through `fem_material_mc_driver` when `METHOD=MC_SUBSTEPPING_SEMISMOOTH`. - [x] Store material-point aggregate diagnostics in `statev(27:32)`: accepted substeps, requested substeps, driver status, branch mask, maximum yield residual and maximum plastic increment. - [x] Keep the default and other continuation methods on the direct single-step Mohr-Coulomb update, while writing consistent single-step diagnostics. - [x] Add structure-level aggregation of MC substep/branch diagnostics to strengthReduction nonlinear chain/cloud output. - [ ] Prove on the 0.75 m PDF cloud longrun that NC-5 reduces material corner cutbacks or local return failures when used as a documented stabilization component. - Keep the first production implementation mutually exclusive through the `METHOD=` selector; if later evidence shows the strongest path is a composition such as `1+2+5`, add explicit secondary flags instead of overloading the primary method id. - Tests: - Add INP parser tests proving omitted keyword selects method `1`, all ids `1..5` and symbolic names are accepted, and invalid values fail before solving. - Add solver diagnostics tests proving the selected method is reported and that method `1` does not regress the existing nonlinear static path. - Add checker coverage for displacement cloud scale and equivalent plastic strain/plastic-zone behavior once the full nonlinear continuation path is available. - Reject linear-static VTK displacement output as reference evidence. - Acceptance: - `examples/strengthReduction` can choose any planned nonlinear continuation method from the INP file, and the default deck uses method `1` without a command-line override. - Method `1` reaches the target `FOS=1.525` PDF route, or the run summary reports a reproducible nonlinear/material failure instead of stopping at an ambiguous partial `accepted_time`. - Strength reduction moves from compact FOS-curve validation to a documented nonlinear structural workflow with PDF displacement/plasticity evidence. - Partial completion evidence for method `1`: - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target strength_reduction_benchmark test_implicit_inp` passed on 2026-06-27. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "implicit_inp|example_strength_reduction_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. - Path smoke passed: `build-win-gcc-16\strength_reduction_benchmark.exe examples\strengthReduction\strength_reduction_slope_static.inp build-win-gcc-16\strength_reduction_twostage_smoke --nonlinear-chain --nl-max-trials 1 --nl-increments 2 --nl-max-newton 3 --nl-linear-iter 100 --nl-tol 1.0e-3`. - Cloud smoke passed: `build-win-gcc-16\strength_reduction_benchmark.exe examples\strengthReduction\strength_reduction_slope_static.inp build-win-gcc-16\strength_reduction_twostage_cloud_smoke --nl-write-cloud --nl-cloud-factor 1.525 --nl-cloud-step 1525 --nl-increments 2 --nl-max-newton 3 --nl-linear-iter 100 --nl-tol 1.0e-3`. - Medium 0.75 m method-1 cloud probe with `--nl-increments 10 --nl-max-newton 20 --nl-linear-iter 1000 --nl-tol 1.0e-3 --nl-preconditioner ilu0` exceeded 120 s and was stopped; full `accepted_time=1.0` remains open. - Completion evidence for method `5` material-point and structure-level diagnostics: - `METHOD=MC_SUBSTEPPING_SEMISMOOTH` routes production `MOHR_COULOMB` updates through `fem_material_mc_driver` and writes `statev(27:32)`. - `strength_reduction_benchmark` now aggregates MC point count, updated points, accepted/requested substeps, limited points, branch mask, maximum yield residual and maximum plastic step into nonlinear chain/cloud/progress rows and summary CSV output. - `examples/strengthReduction/check_strength_reduction_results.py` rejects missing or invalid MC row/summary diagnostics. - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target strength_reduction_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-27. - Nonlinear chain/cloud smoke output under `build-win-gcc-16\strength_reduction_mc_diag_smoke` passed `examples\strengthReduction\check_strength_reduction_results.py`, including optional MC chain/cloud/progress diagnostics. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "material_mohr_coulomb|implicit_inp|example_strength_reduction_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. - Completion evidence for method `2`: - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target test_solver_implicit test_implicit_inp strength_reduction_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-27. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "solver_implicit|implicit_inp|example_strength_reduction_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. - `solver_implicit` now verifies adaptive growth reaches the final static time with fewer accepted increments than the fixed initial step would use. - `implicit_inp` verifies `METHOD=ADAPTIVE_TARGET_NEWTON`, `TARGET_NEWTON`, `GROWTH` and `SHRINK`, including failure without changing previous valid settings. - `examples/strengthReduction/check_strength_reduction_results.py` now rejects malformed nonlinear chain/cloud diagnostics for target increment, accepted increment, next target increment and adjustment reason. - Completion evidence for method `3`: - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target test_solver_implicit test_implicit_inp strength_reduction_benchmark` passed on 2026-06-27. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "solver_implicit|implicit_inp|example_strength_reduction_benchmark" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. - `solver_implicit` now verifies that `METHOD=TRUST_REGION_DAMPED_NEWTON` limits the applied correction norm, converges through multiple damped Newton iterations, updates trust diagnostics and preserves the expected displacement solution. - `implicit_inp` verifies all trust-region control parameters and confirms invalid trust radius bounds fail without mutating previous valid settings. - `examples/strengthReduction/check_strength_reduction_results.py` now rejects missing or invalid trust-radius, damping, merit-ratio and rejection-count diagnostics in nonlinear chain/cloud/progress output. - Partial completion evidence for method `4`: - `fem_control` now owns a dynamically sized accepted-increment continuation path table; `fem_solver_implicit` records direct displacement-control rows after nonlinear static increments converge, while the active load factor is still the one used by the solved increment. - `fem_api` exposes row-by-row continuation path access and `fem_output_csv` writes `continuation_path.csv` when path data exists. - `tests/data/c3d4_static_arc_disp_continuation.inp` selects `METHOD=ARC_LENGTH_OR_DISPLACEMENT_CONTROL`; `implicit_inp` verifies the API path rows and `solver_implicit` verifies the in-memory path. - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target test_solver_implicit test_implicit_inp` passed on 2026-06-27. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "solver_implicit|implicit_inp" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. - Partial completion evidence for method `5`: - `src/base/fem_control.f90` now stores MC substep controls and `src/input/fem_inp_helpers.f90` parses/validates them from `*NONLINEAR CONTINUATION`. - `src/material/fem_material_j2.f90` now dispatches production `MOHR_COULOMB` updates to `fem_material_mc_driver` only when `METHOD=MC_SUBSTEPPING_SEMISMOOTH`. - `src/material/fem_material_mohr_coulomb.f90` now writes consistent single-step state diagnostics and reserves `statev(27:32)` for MC substep aggregates. - `cmake --build build-win-gcc-16 --config Release --target test_material_mohr_coulomb test_implicit_inp` passed on 2026-06-27. - `ctest --test-dir build-win-gcc-16 -C Release -R "material_mohr_coulomb|implicit_inp" --output-on-failure` passed on 2026-06-27. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-4: Move buckling and cyclic symmetry into the main solver path - Source: - V5.5 and `examples/buckling_corrugated_shell` remain `PARTIAL`. - Implementation: - Add a general `*BUCKLING` step to the main `femlite` input/solve flow. - Assemble shell and solid geometric stiffness after static preload through the production element/solver path. - Integrate modal output with the normal output workflow. - Bring cyclic sector constraints into the main solve path, including node pairing, coordinate rotation and shell rotational DOF mapping. - Upgrade corrugated shell coverage from compact cyclic benchmark to a full shell FE preload-buckling high-fidelity model. - Tests: - Add input-level `*BUCKLING` tests, preload-to-buckling tests and cyclic sector shell/solid mapping tests. - Keep Euler column and compact corrugated benchmark as regression coverage. - Acceptance: - Users can run a buckling workflow through normal INP input, not only through benchmark helper tools. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-5: Promote roll forming from benchmark helpers to production workflow - Source: - V5.6 and `examples/roll_forming` remain `PARTIAL`. - Implementation: - Add a main-solver roll-forming process step or equivalent production workflow for rigid roller kinematics, rotation, friction, plastic forming and unloading/springback. - Support full 3D workpiece meshes, not only compact section benchmarks. - Define restart-driven multi-step process semantics for forming and springback. - Add larger longrun stability checks for the process flow. - Tests: - Keep roller kinematics and compact J2 springback benchmarks as regression. - Add a full 3D workpiece run with restart, unloading, residual displacement and plastic-zone checks. - Acceptance: - Roll forming no longer depends on benchmark-specific orchestration for the core process path. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-6: Integrate cohesive contact into the main contact workflow - Source: - V5.7 and `examples/ball_adhesion_decohesion` remain `PARTIAL`. - Implementation: - Integrate cohesive law/state/metrics into the production contact solve, including normal/tangential traction, damage evolution, unloading/reload and energy output. - Implement ordinary contact to cohesive contact switching rules and the reverse/released-state handling where applicable. - Add tangent support for cohesive contact and restart persistence for damage, maximum opening, adhesion energy and decohesion state. - Upgrade the ball-adhesion example from compact cohesive ring benchmark to a full ball-membrane FE cohesive contact long path. - Tests: - Extend restart tests to cohesive damage/history fields. - Add full FE force-displacement, hysteresis, dissipated energy, damage and decohesion-area checks. - Acceptance: - Cohesive behavior is available through the main contact workflow and not only through single-integration-point or benchmark-only drivers. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-7: Upgrade deferred and partial high-fidelity examples - Source: - `docs/v5_development_plan.md` lists several example directories as `DEFERRED` or `PARTIAL`. - Implementation: - Upgrade `examples/shell_solid_connection` from shared-node smoke to a high-fidelity shell-solid connection/contact benchmark with transition-zone stress and contact-pressure checks. - Upgrade `examples/buckling_corrugated_shell` to a complete shell FE preload-buckling model after main solver `*BUCKLING` support exists. - Upgrade `examples/roll_forming` to a full 3D workpiece benchmark after the production roll-forming workflow exists. - Upgrade `examples/ball_adhesion_decohesion` to a full FE cohesive ball-membrane benchmark after main contact integration exists. - Extend `examples/Dynamic_Grain_Packing_of_a_Flexible_Container` with larger particle counts, neighbor-search performance checks and longrun energy stability. - Tests: - Each upgraded example needs a README, input/generator, run script, checker, CTest entry and documented reference metrics/tolerances. - Acceptance: - No example is listed as V5 PASS if it is still a compact surrogate, fallback path or smoke-only run. ### [ ] TODO V5.12-8: Complete longrun and performance close-out - Source: - V5.9/V5.10 remain `PARTIAL` in the development plan because larger longrun and full performance close-out remain recommended. - Implementation: - Define longrun tiers for contact, Mohr-Coulomb, buckling, roll forming, cohesive contact and particle-container coupling. - Record memory, iteration, residual, timing and platform stability metrics. - Update `docs/v5_benchmark_matrix.md` when new longrun/performance tests are formalized. - Tests: - Add documented extended commands for longrun/performance suites, separate from default fast CTest. - Re-run relevant Windows GCC, Windows Intel/MSVC and WSL GNU subsets when longrun coverage changes. - Acceptance: - V5 performance and longrun coverage has clear commands, output metrics, tolerances and platform records.