Kirsch Plate
FemLite static shell benchmark for the Kirsch infinite plate problem.
The benchmark data follow models.sme.kirsch_plate.pdf in this directory:
- Geometry: quarter model of a 2 m x 2 m plate with a central circular hole.
- Modeled domain: x in [0, 1] m, y in [0, 1] m.
- Hole radius: 0.1 m.
- Thickness: 0.1 m.
- Material: E = 2.1E11 Pa, nu = 0.3.
- Load: distributed stress sigma_x = 1000 Pa on the right edge.
- Constraints: symmetry on x = 0 and y = 0.
- FemLite representation: linear shell membrane model, with all out-of-plane translations and rotations constrained to form a plane-stress benchmark.
Generated decks:
krisch_tri.inp: S3 triangular shell mesh, 1025 nodes, 1920 elements.kirsch_quad.inp: S4 quadrilateral shell mesh, 1025 nodes, 960 elements.
Regenerate the decks:
Python\.venv\Scripts\python.exe examples\Kirsch\generate_kirsch.py
Run the static cases from the repository root:
New-Item -ItemType Directory -Force examples\Kirsch\results\tri_static | Out-Null
build-win-gcc-16\femlite.exe examples\Kirsch\krisch_tri.inp --output-dir examples\Kirsch\results\tri_static --static-linear
New-Item -ItemType Directory -Force examples\Kirsch\results\quad_static | Out-Null
build-win-gcc-16\femlite.exe examples\Kirsch\kirsch_quad.inp --output-dir examples\Kirsch\results\quad_static --static-linear
The PDF uses the Kirsch analytical stress along the vertical symmetry line:
sigma_x(y) = 1000 / 2 * (2 + (0.1/y)^2 + 3*(0.1/y)^4)
Therefore:
- Near hole, y = 0.1 m: sigma_x = 3000 Pa.
- Away from hole, y = 1.0 m: sigma_x = 1005.15 Pa.
The PDF reports finite-plate errors relative to the analytical solution:
| Location | PDF finite plate error | PDF infinite plate error |
|---|---|---|
| Near hole | 1.1% | 0.2% |
| Away from hole | -4.0% | -0.1% |
FemLite comparison below uses global plane-stress sigma_x recovered from the computed nodal displacements at the nearest elements touching the x = 0 symmetry edge. This is a discrete element-point comparison, not a line-probe postprocess with nodal extrapolation.
| Deck | Sample point | Element | Sample y | FemLite sigma_x | Analytical sigma_x at PDF point | FemLite error vs PDF point | Analytical sigma_x at sample y | FemLite error vs sample y |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
krisch_tri.inp |
near hole | 1874 | 0.100958 | 3030.09 Pa | 3000.00 Pa | 1.00% | 2934.44 Pa | 3.26% |
krisch_tri.inp |
away from hole | 1919 | 0.977874 | 965.05 Pa | 1005.15 Pa | -3.99% | 1005.39 Pa | -4.01% |
kirsch_quad.inp |
near hole | 937 | 0.101437 | 2968.95 Pa | 3000.00 Pa | -1.03% | 2902.75 Pa | 2.28% |
kirsch_quad.inp |
away from hole | 960 | 0.966813 | 971.47 Pa | 1005.15 Pa | -3.35% | 1005.52 Pa | -3.39% |
The S3 result closely reproduces the PDF finite-plate errors at both benchmark locations. The S4 result is also within a few percent; its far-field drift is consistent with the finite-plate trend reported by the PDF.